This highly-anticipated crossover set for Magic: The Gathering themed to TMNT has not even hit shelves, but it's already stirring up immense anticipation. Boasting stunning artwork showcasing countless iterations of the heroes, the cards draw from sources ranging from the comic books to classic animated series, films, and even niche action figures.
For those who are a enthusiast of the half-shell heroes who additionally plays Magic: The Gathering, this is the time you've been waiting for. Then we have fans such as myself. As a life-long TMNT fanatic obsessed since childhood, that doesn't know anything about the card game. I've never played a hand. Yet, I'm incredibly excited about this crossover. My excitement stems from a passion for the franchise and the amazing lore represented on these pieces of cardstock. I adore them so much that I've picked out the 10 best cards in the entire set, judged solely on their "cool factor" of TMNT canon. Are they competitive in an actual game? I have no idea, and I'm in the dark. A slight letdown is the glaring omission of any reference to the legendary Coming Out of Their Shells tour, which feels like a missed opportunity.
10. A Classic Comic Moment
The image on this card is pulled directly from the 11th issue of the original comic series, showcasing co-creator Kevin Eastman's early depiction of April O'Neil. This version is an often-cited piece of comic book history, showcasing her later look into a brunette reporter in a yellow jumpsuit from the cartoon.
9. Shellshock
Like a number of other cards, Shellshock is a direct homage to iconic TMNT video games. In the first arcade game, the Turtles could be electrocuted by a enemy named Roadkill Rodney, creating a comical visual gag that is exactly captured here. This moment grew into a signature bit in later games and was even immortalized as an action figure in 2020.
8. Deep-Cut Villainy
We must take a moment to acknowledge that a card was created based on Tempestra, a largely obscure single-episode antagonist from a 1990 episode of the cartoon. In the notable episode, Leonardo gets hooked on a video game featuring this digital foe, who is somehow manifested during an electrical storm. While the episode may not be considered a masterpiece, the fact that the set's creators went so far into the archives of TMNT antagonists is truly respectable.
7. Fast Forward
This set features multiple homages to the excellent 1991 arcade classic Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Turtles in Time. Fast Forward is notable because the flavor text at the bottom specifically references the "Neon Night Riders" level, a memorable stage where the camera changes to a third-person view for a skateboard sequence leading to a climactic fight against Krang.
6. Alien Greasers
For anyone who was a kid watching the first TMNT animated series, the Neutrinos were definitely the coolest. These three greaser-inspired aliens, first appearing in the episode "Hot Rodding Teenagers," communicated with high-pitched squeaks, piloted a cool vehicle, and constantly brought chaos. This card beautifully encapsulates the spirit of these fun-loving characters.
5. Leonardo, Sewer Samurai Art Card
As a longtime TMNT enthusiast, it's gratifying to see a card inspired by a specific action figure, rather than a cartoon or movie. The franchise's heyday in the late 20th century was full of one-off action figures. This special card features a stunning drawing of Leonardo as he appeared in the 1990s "Sewer Samurai" action figure, a design that wasn't featured in any media but is now honored here. Those interested, this special art card has more common foil versions available as well.
4. A Goofy Movie Moment
Although Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II: The Secret of the Ooze was a sillier sequel, it introduced the mutant villains Tokka and Rahzar. Tainted Treats depicts the climax where Donatello and Professor Jordan Perry create an "mutagen counter-agent", freeze it, and use them against the creatures. This is a quirky slice of movie lore captured on cardboard.
3. A Gritty Comic Homage
Several cards reference the acclaimed 2020 comic Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: The Last Ronin, but this one most powerfully conveys the story's core anguish. The tale centers on the sole survivor Turtle fighting in a ravaged New York, channeling all the grief and devastation of witnessing his family. This is a somber but profoundly resonant story that fans had been waiting for.
2. Turtles Forever
This card is like a love letter for longtime fans. While evoking the 2009 animated film, it one-ups it by featuring the movie version of Donatello with his cartoon counterparts. The amusing scale is endearing, and although it would have been the ideal place for a keytar nod to Coming Out of Their Shells, the image stands as a fantastic tribute of the Turtles' varied history.
1. A Nostalgic Challenge
Choosing this card as the top was a tough call. Its image is pulled from the box art of the notorious 1989 NES Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles game, a core experience for countless fans. When we got that game, many thought it was a port of the arcade hit. We were mistaken.
The NES game was a brutally difficult side-scroller that didn't capture the fun of the cartoon. Yet, it was the only TMNT game at home for a while. Taking Splinter's lessons, I practiced and tried to beat it.
I failed. Even now, I can't defeat it. That notorious underwater level with the deadly plants was the worst. But, the joy was in the struggle, a sentiment this card perfectly captures.